You may have gotten a letter like this from your lawyer. The Board panel ruled against you, either on your own appeal of a judge's decision or after the insurance carrier appealed a decision you had won. Your next option, the letter says, is an appeal to the Appellate Division, Third Department. Then it says the firm does not handle those appeals, and if you want to pursue one you will need to find another lawyer.
Schotter Millican has handled more than 100 Third Department appeals, and we are one of the few firms representing injured workers in New York that does them regularly. Not every Board panel loss is worth taking to court. There are other grounds, but in our experience most winning appeals come down to one of three, and below is a case we won for each.
What the Court Can and Cannot Fix
Your Board hearings may have felt like court: a judge, testimony, a lawyer on the other side. But the Workers' Compensation Board is a state agency, part of the executive branch, much like the agency that decides unemployment claims. It runs hearings less formally than a courtroom and is not bound by the rules of evidence a court has to follow.
The Appellate Division, Third Department, is part of the state court system, and it is the court that reviews Board decisions. It reviews them under the substantial evidence standard. As long as there is some evidence in the record supporting the Board's choice, the court cannot touch it. That holds even if the judges privately think your doctor was more believable than the carrier's.
So the question for any appeal is whether your case has the kind of problem the court is allowed to fix. The three most common are below. (For the full appeal process, from the first Board panel appeal through the Court of Appeals, see our guide to workers' comp appeals in New York.)
1. The Finding Had No Real Evidence Behind It
A retired subway train car inspector brought a hearing loss claim. His doctor measured about 45% hearing loss, a substantial amount and worth a good deal of money. The insurance carrier's IME doctor found about 3%, worth next to nothing.
The Board sided with the IME doctor. Its reason: the worker's doctor had not explained how someone who had lost almost half his hearing could have kept working with no problems.
We appealed. Nobody had ever asked the worker's doctor to explain that, and neither side had raised how well he did his job. When the Board makes a medical finding, it needs evidence in the record to support it, and the Board's only reason here was one it came up with on its own. The Third Department reversed (read the decision).
2. The Board Got the Law Wrong
New York has special rules for workers who took part in the rescue, recovery and cleanup after 9/11, not only first responders. The law lists the injuries and illnesses that qualify, and musculoskeletal injuries are on that list.
Our client was an asbestos handler on the World Trade Center cleanup, filling and carrying 30 to 60 bags of dust and debris a day, and his back gave out. The Board disallowed the back claim, holding that it was not a qualifying condition under the 9/11 provisions.
That is a pure question of law, and on questions of law the court decides what the law means. We pointed to the plain words of the statute and to research into what the Legislature intended. The Third Department held that his back condition was a musculoskeletal disease covered by the 9/11 provisions, and that the claim should not have been disallowed (read the decision).
3. The Board Ignored Its Own Precedent
Another hearing loss client: his doctor found about 71% hearing loss, and the carrier's IME doctor found about 25%. But the IME doctor did not attach an audiogram to the report. An audiogram is the chart that shows how loud a sound has to be before a person can hear it, at different frequencies, in each ear.
The Board's own earlier decisions said that a permanent hearing loss report without an audiogram does not count. Here, the Board relied on the IME report anyway and never explained why it was departing from those decisions.
When the Board breaks its own precedent without explanation, the court can step in. The decision was reversed and sent back (read the decision), and the case later settled for a substantial amount.
Winning Sends the Case Back to the Board
A reversal does not end the case. The Third Department sends it back to the Board with instructions to issue a new Board panel decision that complies with the court's order.
The Board does not always take a reversal well. Sometimes the new decision rules against the worker again on a different ground that the Board says is consistent with the court's order. Then there is a second decision to make: go back to the Third Department, or leave it there. You and your attorney decide whether to appeal again, and sometimes the better choice is to stop there.
If Your Lawyer Says They Don't Do These Appeals
Watch the clock first. The notice of appeal to the Third Department is due within 30 days of the filing date of the Board panel decision. It is a one-page document, but once the 30 days pass, the chance to have the court review the panel's decision is gone. Applying for full Board review does not stop that clock.
If you like your lawyer, you do not have to leave them to have us handle the appeal. We often work alongside a client's own lawyer in these cases. We read the decision before taking a case, and if an appeal is not worth your time or money, we will tell you.
Ask us to review your Board panel decision. If you have a copy of the decision, keep it handy.
Key Takeaways
- The Third Department cannot re-weigh credibility. It reverses mainly for no substantial evidence, an error of law, or an unexplained break from Board precedent
- A medical finding needs a doctor behind it. The Board's own medical conclusions are no substitute for a doctor's opinion
- A reversal sends the case back to the Board, which issues a new decision, and that decision can be appealed again
- The notice of appeal is due within 30 days of the Board panel decision's filing date, and your current lawyer can keep handling everything before the Board while another firm handles the appeal
Lost at the Board panel and unsure whether to appeal?
Workers’ compensation is what we do. At Schotter Millican, LLP, we represent injured workers across New York City, and we have never represented an insurance company or carrier.
Call (718) 770-3708 for a free case review. No fee unless we win.
Hablamos español — llame al (718) 770-3708.
Mówimy po polsku — zadzwoń (718) 770-3708.